Skip navigation
Sidebar -

Advanced search options →

Welcome

Welcome to CEMB forum.
Please login or register. Did you miss your activation email?

Donations

Help keep the Forum going!
Click on Kitty to donate:

Kitty is lost

Recent Posts


New Britain
Yesterday at 03:10 PM

German nationalist party ...
Yesterday at 01:11 PM

Do humans have needed kno...
February 06, 2025, 03:13 PM

Lights on the way
by akay
February 05, 2025, 10:04 PM

Gaza assault
February 05, 2025, 10:04 AM

AMRIKAAA Land of Free .....
February 03, 2025, 09:25 AM

The origins of Judaism
by zeca
February 02, 2025, 04:29 PM

Qur'anic studies today
by zeca
February 01, 2025, 11:48 PM

Random Islamic History Po...
by zeca
February 01, 2025, 07:29 PM

اضواء على الطريق ....... ...
by akay
February 01, 2025, 11:55 AM

News From Syria
by zeca
December 28, 2024, 12:29 AM

Mo Salah
December 26, 2024, 05:30 AM

Theme Changer

 Topic: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)

 (Read 4898 times)
  • 1« Previous thread | Next thread »
  • Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     OP - May 20, 2012, 08:03 AM

    So my lovely Egyptian friend sent me this super flowery website "Women and Islam page. To further educate me on how amazing Islam treats women.

    So skimmed through and I couldn't help but notice some interesting trends that seem to show up while answering the tough questions about the treatment of women in Islam. Im just sharin my thoughts on a few things that caught my eye.


    Quote
    http://www.islamswomen.com/articles/women_in_quran_and_sunnah.php
    "For Muslim men and women, for believing men and women, for devout men and women, for true men and women, for men and women who are patient and constant, for men and women who humble themselves, for men and women who give in charity, for men and women who fast, for men and women who guard their chastity, and for men and women who engage much in Allah's praise, for them has Allah prepared forgiveness and great reward." [Noble Quran 33:35]

    This clearly contradicts the assertion of the Christian Fathers that women do not possess souls and that they will exist as sexless beings in the next life. The Quran says that women have souls in exactly the same way as men and will enter Paradise if they do good:

    Conditions 1,400 Years Ago

    Now let us do some basic research here. We begin by looking into the condition of the women in various societies at the time 1,400 years ago when Allah revealed the Quran to Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him.

    Pagan Arabs - Burying Girls Alive


    During that time the pagan Arab men used to bury their newborn daughters alive in the sand, out of shame for having something so low and disgusting like a girl instead of a son. Women were treated horribly and with utter disgust.

    Men could marry as many as they liked and very often they owned women like cattle or sheep. There were no laws to protect the women and they had no rights at all.

    Christians - Arguing If Women Had Souls


    Christians at that time were holding council meetings to determine whether or not a woman even had a soul. The church blamed "Eve" the mother of all humans after Adam (peace and blessings be upon him) for the "original sin" and damned her and her seed for what she had done.

    Priests - Best Men - Forbidden Marriage - To Any Women

    Priests, bishops, cardinals and even the Pope are the very best of the Catholic men within the church. Yet the church still forbids their clergymen the chance for marriage and families. This unnatural situation has caused very serious ramifications throughout the society around the world.

    Nuns - Best Women - No Marriage - No Children


    Nuns are the very best of the Catholic women. They cover themselves in proper attire much the same way as the Muslim women. Yet, they are never allowed to marry or have children throughout their lives. This unnatural condition has caused untold number of disgraceful and disgusting practices within the very church itself.



    So a few things I have to complain about with these arguments. Arguing Islam treats women better than other religions today, based on past beliefs. Christian practices were pretty fucked up in those days, and most Christians today know it. Which is why it has been reformed into many sects to move away from those practices.


    Also I don't see what the big deal is with nuns and priests (attempting) to abstain from sex. The best women and men? I find this ironic since Islam does practices that could be arguably considered unnatural. such as fasting when the body craves  and pains for food, for God. Or circumcism of genitals which a child is naturally born with.  So why criticize orthodox Christians who work under the church for abstaining from sex ( by choice)  as unnatural. They do so for the same reason Muslims go to fast. Devotion and to move away from worldly pleasures to focus entirely on God etc. etc.

    Also both Islam and the Catholic church has had, and currently has, disgusting things happening within them. So finger pointing is just BS and I don't buy it.
    Also Catholicism is one out of over 12 different churches sects. And I went to a church where the minister was married with kids. So if you want to compare to Catholics fine ( because I think many Catholic practices are fucked up anyways) but you can't use Catholic practices and say all Christians think and behave like that because Catholicism no loner represents Christians. 

     
    ---

    Yes we know When Islam and Mo' came, thousands of years ago the treatment of women was improved. I completely agree. However, I feel Islam has fallen behind the times and still think the way they view women is the best treatment and its not. No civilized person today buries children or debates if women have souls so I don't understand why this is even an argument.



    Also I hate when Islam calls women gems, and jewels. I for one don't care for Jewelry and precious metals. They are given value based on man's perception, and then men fight over, steal and kill for these 'Gems'. Gems, pearls, etc. these are all symbols of greed. :/ Real beautiful things in life are in nature, and nature is open for everyone to enjoy so long as u take care of it. UG I hate comparing women to precious gems it makes me annoyed >:[ man's precious possession is responsible for most of the bloodshed today. Be it possession of land, gold, money whatever. Women are better than that.

    Quote
    Women Need Husbands - Allah Provided the Answer
    http://www.islamswomen.com/marriage/man_can_marry_four_why_not_women_marry_four.php


    The prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) predicted that in the Last Days the women would outnumber the men to a great extent. Today we are seeing this become a reality all over the world. Allah has already provided for us for this occasion. After all, He is the One who makes it all happen and He already knew that many women would come into Islam in these days. He also knew many of the Muslim men would be killed or die at an early age, just as it is happening these days. These women all need husbands. Allah has given us the solution to all of life's problems.


    I just don't even know how to respond to this. Partner, companion yes? But some women do just fine with other women, not necessarily a man. so Allah might have screwed up somewhere. Also  Allah is not going to protect the young devout Muslim men from dying, but don't worry all the women will find new husbands. Ah praise Allah so thoughtful, solution to all of life's problems.:> Really?! That just makes no damn sense. >:[
    [/quote]

    Also I'm really sick of Islam comparing itself to Christianity all the time which one of the worst, how about a comparison to Buddhism, or Taoism, or some of different Christian sects. There are many other religions out there, or spiritual practices.

    Regardless of some of criticisms I have, I really enjoy sites like this because in the face of criticism Muslim women have begun cherry picking from the Quran whatever, what their right are even if some sunnahs do contradict it. So now they have to prove they aren't oppressed by not taking shit from men who say otherwise. Which is kind of in the step of the right direction.

    Thoughts?

    ***~Church is where bad people go to hide~***
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #1 - May 20, 2012, 08:34 AM

    THoughts Huh?

    you already elaborated them well.

    I would wanna go through them one by one:

    1. Pagan Arabs burying their baby girls alive.

    Well you ONLY need common sense to figure out that burying people alive is evil, I really didn't need anyone or any scripture to tell me that burying my sister baby or daughter is evil.
    That is just common sense thus invalid argument.

    2. Christians - Arguing If Women Had Souls

    Doesn't really matter what Christians argued back then, did Jesus say that woman have no souls ?? does the bible say that or Christians argued that just because they were ignorant, if Jesus and the bible never said that then this argument can easily be refuted and it doesn't really matter what kind of stuff did the medieval christians argue, muslims as well still do argue some lame stupid shit, hanging gay people and stuff like that.

    3. Priests - Best Men - Forbidden Marriage - To Any Women

    Priests = best men Huh?? really? this doesn't even need any refutation.

    It is not good for priests to eschew sexual activity and it is good to encourage Muslim man to join war and get killed.

    Whatever, this is not even an argument since priests are not best man, it is laughable.

    4. Nuns = best woman

    Look up at the priests = best man argument.

    5. Women need husbands.

    I think you already elaborated this very well.

  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #2 - May 20, 2012, 10:17 AM

    Good points Sakura, you've expressed yourself well!  Afro


    Quote
    Quote
    Nuns are the very best of the Catholic women. They cover themselves in proper attire much the same way as the Muslim women. Yet, they are never allowed to marry or have children throughout their lives. This unnatural condition has caused untold number of disgraceful and disgusting practices within the very church itself.



    Haha, what disgraceful and disgusting practices? Sleeping with other nuns? Oh, so shameful!  Cheesy

    I read a book a few years back about all these nuns who'd since come out of the closet and that the biggest reason for becoming nuns was 'cause back in the day it was expected women would marry and they couldn't bring themselves to marrying a man when they were attracted to the same sex and not the male sex.

    This argument of theirs is null on this point 'cause it only applies to those who consider homosexuality as being evil. If you look at practices conducted by some nuns and priests in catholic schools where child-abuse and sexual abuse went on/still happens, all I can say is this:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-15256764

    and

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-stoke-staffordshire-12780538

    Child abuse happens, whether by those who are "celebate" or those who are married with kids.

    Quote
    Also I hate when Islam calls women gems, and jewels. I for one don't care for Jewelry and precious metals. They are given value based on man's perception, and then men fight over, steal and kill for these 'Gems'. Gems, pearls, etc. these are all symbols of greed. :/ Real beautiful things in life are in nature, and nature is open for everyone to enjoy so long as u take care of it. UG I hate comparing women to precious gems it makes me annoyed >:[ man's precious possession is responsible for most of the bloodshed today. Be it possession of land, gold, money whatever. Women are better than that.


    Exactly, why are women being compared to gems, it just shows up the whole thinking behind it that women are possesion, owned, property. It's not freedom, it's owning a woman, and even if we women were treated as precious as gems, I certainly wouldn't want to be owned, it goes with the whole argument as to why women should cover up, 'cause they are their husband's property and another man might want to steal her.

    With embarrassment, I used to quote the argument of women being like gems. Very embarrassed about it now lol. Where was my head back then?
    Quote
    Quote
    Women Need Husbands - Allah Provided the Answer
    http://www.islamswomen.com/marriage/man_can_marry_four_why_not_women_marry_four.php


    The prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) predicted that in the Last Days the women would outnumber the men to a great extent. Today we are seeing this become a reality all over the world. Allah has already provided for us for this occasion. After all, He is the One who makes it all happen and He already knew that many women would come into Islam in these days. He also knew many of the Muslim men would be killed or die at an early age, just as it is happening these days. These women all need husbands. Allah has given us the solution to all of life's problems.



    The prophet also said that the vast majourity of people in jahannam would be women (Bukhari). Goes to show how much Allah loves us women huh? Creates the majourity of us for the hell-fire.

    And exactly why do women need a husband? Many women are quite content being single, and some women like other women in *that* way, and some have been so traumatized by past relationships that they don't want a man around. A good friend of mine who is Bi doesn't ever plan on getting married again, in fact she doesn't even want sex. She's a highly paid professional who has a beautiful house, a gorgeous hair cut and enjoys life to the full. She certainly doesn't think she's hard done by in being single.

    Wasn't Hanbali single for his whole life? I remember asking someone why couldn't women be single if a great islamic scholar could do so for his whole life, and the answer I got was that women are more prone to sexual immorality.  015 Fucking nutters.

    I remember sheikh Khalid Yasin giving a lecture on why polygamy is encouraged in Islam, I actually attended a lecture of his here in Australia when he came here before he wasn't allowed back in by the Aussie government that is, anyways, he said that women had no right to complain or threaten their husband's with divorce if he marries another woman. He said that 'cause of how many men out there that are gay or in jail or alcoholics etc... that women should think of their sisters who don't have husbands and be selfless in being ok with their husbands getting a second wife, that women should do for their muslim sisters what they would do for themselves, that is let their sister have a husband by letting her husband marrying him. Forget what men get out of it, apparently it's all about love of our sisters!  Roll Eyes Cheesy

    Meh, whatever, my X used to go on and on about second wife, this second wife that second wife, four boobs, four vaginas, YaAllah, imagine four breasts! She would make a good second wife, look at the rack on that! so on and so forth. Bugging me on and on about how he was going to get a second wife, and would even go on muslim online matrimonal sites IN FRONT of me to look for one, and at first I was jealous and hurt but towards the end of our marriage I was like, well FUCKING go do it, 'cause I don't want to have anything to do with you, go fucking get another wife and let her put up with you. I even begged him at one point to marry a second wife and let me live alone with the kids and him not come near me, that I would fully support him marrying a second wife if he would leave me alone and not live/have sex/come near me or the kids and that in return I would be his wife in name and would stay faithful to him but live on my own with the kids and him not come near us.
    But he was like, "What would be the point in that? I want you AND a second wife. There's no point if I can't have you as well."

    The fucker shoulda gone gotten one, 'cause I'm gone now!  dance In court he told the judge that he still considered me his wife even though we got divorced, which I dunno how he figures 'cause with me being a murtad it completely nullifies our marriage Hehe  dance, and then he told the court that he is looking for another wife (straight after saying that me divorcing him according to australian law isn't valid islamically and that I'm still his wife according to Islam so in essence he was telling the court that he's looking for a second wife) and that he hopes I'll come back to him so that we can have one big happy family.  idiot2 The ICL asked him if he married again, that considering he considers me to still be his wife that in looking for another woman to marry, that he would be in fact getting a second wife, and he said, "Yes, well, ahhh, yes, but no, if she (meaning me) comes back to me, then I won't get a second wife, unless she (me) agrees to it."  Cheesy Cheesy Cheesy Yeah fucking right.  Roll Eyes

    Now am I happy being single? For sure. Do I get lonely sometimes? Yes. But the last thing I need in my life right now is a man.

    I could live out my days single.  Afro Where on earth do people get the idea that just 'cause your single that you must be pining away for a man? Some do, but many of us single women aren't.

    I agree Sakura, silly arguments they make and I know when I was muslim I was constantly struggling to come up with arguments as to why women are treated at least ok in islam. It was a waging inner battle though as the evidence to the contrary was so strong, and at times I'd be left thinking, "Why am I arguing for Islam on this?" but kept up 'cause I thought it was my islamic duty or something. So sad. And such an embarrassment that I was part of the whole dawah machine, though I don't think I was very convincing lol, my heart wasn't in it, felt guilty about saying things about why Islam is so great when I didn't really believe what I was saying anyway.
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #3 - May 20, 2012, 10:46 AM



    1. Pagan Arabs burying their baby girls alive.

    Well you ONLY need common sense to figure out that burying people alive is evil, I really didn't need anyone or any scripture to tell me that burying my sister baby or daughter is evil.
    That is just common sense thus invalid argument.



    Just to play devil's advocate here but I disagree with this statement.  I would have thought it would be common sense not to enslave other humans and yet there was a time in the world in which slavery was pretty much a standard accepted practise.  If it is true (and so far I haven't seen proof) that pre-islam used to bury their daughters, then to them it would have been somewhat normal to do it/consider it, or rail against it.

    I mean there was a time in the world when people left crippled babies or weaker babies out to die in the night, believing that if their 'gods' wanted it, the baby would survive and if it didn't then better for it in the end,  Just think Spartans.

    What is common sense in one generation could be seen as ridiculous to another.

    Meh, whatever, my X used to go on and on about second wife, this second wife that second wife, four boobs, four vaginas, YaAllah, imagine four breasts! She would make a good second wife, look at the rack on that! so on and so forth. Bugging me on and on about how he was going to get a second wife, and would even go on muslim online matrimonal sites IN FRONT of me to look for one, and at first I was jealous and hurt but towards the end of our marriage I was like, well FUCKING go do it, 'cause I don't want to have anything to do with you, go fucking get another wife and let her put up with you. I even begged him at one point to marry a second wife and let me live alone with the kids and him not come near me, that I would fully support him marrying a second wife if he would leave me alone and not live/have sex/come near me or the kids and that in return I would be his wife in name and would stay faithful to him but live on my own with the kids and him not come near us.
    But he was like, "What would be the point in that? I want you AND a second wife. There's no point if I can't have you as well."


    Pretty much the same story for me dude Grin

    Only difference is he never talked about 4 wives or another wife on earth, he talked more about the houris or the sexy jinn that sometimes marry men.  Human women were something he hated I think.

    It was me begging him to consider a second wife since he was so clearly unhappy with me and hated me so much based on his behaviour.  At first it was me trying to convince him out of love for him that if I really wasn't good enough then I understood and he could have a second wife. and then later it was just me wanting peace and quiet from him, to be spared his misery and violence which as he said was only something I brought out of him.

    I remember going through a phase in which I felt guilty looking back, that I could ever have wished him on another woman, but then I realised I wasn't wishing HIM on another woman because I believed wholeheartedly that I was the one to blame, he was only violent to me because it was ME, so i wasn't wishing his violence on another woman, since she would be better than me.  Roll Eyes 

    It was him who always said he had no interest in a second wife, as if that was a relief to me Grin    Nope.  he was all houris and stunning otherworldly beauty etc.

    Anyway fuck him.  Fuck his memory. Assholes. 

    Inhale the good shit, exhale the bullshit.
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #4 - May 20, 2012, 10:51 AM

    What a dick.

    "Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom." - Viktor E. Frankl

    'Life is just the extreme expression of complex chemistry' - Neil deGrasse Tyson
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #5 - May 20, 2012, 11:08 AM

    Just to play devil's advocate here but I disagree with this statement.  I would have thought it would be common sense not to enslave other humans and yet there was a time in the world in which slavery was pretty much a standard accepted practise.  If it is true (and so far I haven't seen proof) that pre-islam used to bury their daughters, then to them it would have been somewhat normal to do it/consider it, or rail against it.

    I mean there was a time in the world when people left crippled babies or weaker babies out to die in the night, believing that if their 'gods' wanted it, the baby would survive and if it didn't then better for it in the end,  Just think Spartans.

    What is common sense in one generation could be seen as ridiculous to another.


    Good point, I think I rushed a bit with that comment.

    Now when I think about it, the same can be said about Human Sacrifice and cannibalism.

    I think the last nights devastating loss of my favorite team has affected my senses.

  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #6 - May 20, 2012, 11:32 AM


    Pretty much the same story for me dude Grin

    Only difference is he never talked about 4 wives or another wife on earth, he talked more about the houris or the sexy jinn that sometimes marry men.  Human women were something he hated I think.



    I know what you mean about the houris thing, my X used to go on about them all the time too, but he still wanted a second wife. I posted last month in the afterlife and beauty thread on this very topic, this is what I said there:

    Fucking houris. It was the bane of my existance whilst married. Houris this, houris that. Fucking houris everywhere and what would I get? A husband who would fuck multiple other women whilst I serve him. Roll Eyes

    Al-Waqi'aah, was one surah I disliked even at my most devout period (astaghfirullah! omg, what a bad muslimah I was to dislike part of the Qu'ran  Shocked), as my X would read it out to me and read the bits on the houroun over and over and over and over and over and over again whilst watching me to try to get a reaction. One day I simply said, well I hope you do go blow yourself up whilst I am still alive so that I can marry another man and won't be with you in jannah, and he jumped up trying to hit me whilst I ran to the bedroom and shoved the chest of drawers up against the door. Hehe, was worth it well and truly!

    It was me begging him to consider a second wife since he was so clearly unhappy with me and hated me so much based on his behaviour.  At first it was me trying to convince him out of love for him that if I really wasn't good enough then I understood and he could have a second wife. and then later it was just me wanting peace and quiet from him, to be spared his misery and violence which as he said was only something I brought out of him.

    I remember going through a phase in which I felt guilty looking back, that I could ever have wished him on another woman, but then I realised I wasn't wishing HIM on another woman because I believed wholeheartedly that I was the one to blame, he was only violent to me because it was ME, so i wasn't wishing his violence on another woman, since she would be better than me.  Roll Eyes  

    It was him who always said he had no interest in a second wife, as if that was a relief to me Grin    Nope.  he was all houris and stunning otherworldly beauty etc.

    Anyway fuck him.  Fuck his memory. Assholes.  



    I know what you mean about feeling guilty for wishing him on another woman, there were times I felt that way too, still feel a little guilty about that as I wouldn't want another woman to go through what I went through, I actually feel really sorry for whoever gets him (or already got I don't know 'cause don't know where he is or what he's doing). I'm really glad that he has police record and convictions and child-protection records for what he put me and the kids through though, as at least I can know that if he stays in Australia and marries again that at least whoever he gets next will have something legally to fall back on if she decides to leave and hopefully whoever she is will wise up quick and get the hell outta there.

    I believed for a long time that his violence was because I wasn't good enough. It took along time for me to start to wize up and realize that it didn't matter what I did or how good I was or whatever, that there was nothing I could do to make him love me or stop being violent towards me. It was so painful to think that some other woman could please him better, he told me time and again that when he got a second wife that she would make him happy, that I was the cause of all his miseries and problems and if only I were better. It really hurt in the begining of our marriage 'cause I would think well if he gets a second wife then he will love her more than me because she's bound to make him happy, but towards the end I couldn't care any more and just wanted him GONE.

    It took me a long time to realize that whoever he married he was going to be an arsehole towards, and that he picked me because I was so messed up from my childhood that I would put up with it. The brainwashing is hard to get rid of though.

    If he'd picked someone else it might have been a different story, he might have ended up being the one being hospitalized and never touching a woman again.

    Meh, painful memories, makes me want to go out and do bad things to violent men who hurt their wives.




  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #7 - May 20, 2012, 06:17 PM

    Just to play devil's advocate here but I disagree with this statement.  I would have thought it would be common sense not to enslave other humans and yet there was a time in the world in which slavery was pretty much a standard accepted practise.  If it is true (and so far I haven't seen proof) that pre-islam used to bury their daughters, then to them it would have been somewhat normal to do it/consider it, or rail against it...




    Yes this is true. In my history classes there were many places all over the world which practiced burying people alive, or human sacrifices etc. . And it's sad yes, but people did not know any better and it's hard for us to understand. However, today we do know better. Humans have evolved socially and mentally over the years. You can't pinpoint one man for being a true prophet because maybe he helped the conditions of slaves, and women. There are so many other figures in history who have done so much better. What about the first people who fought against slavery? Why is Muhammad held up as being so great for 'improving' slaves and women conditions, whilst the non-Muslims who fought and are still fighting to abolish slavery and demand equality for women are consider murtads going to hell because they are Jewish, or Christian or non-believers. They all are forgotten whilst one figure demands all the praise.

    Anyways sorry that both you and Da_Dude, had to put up with that I can't even imagine because I'm 24 and not even married yet =p. 'Marriage' to me just seems like a term and process you go through to show off to other people. You can live with someone and have kids and not be 'married' partnership is more than just vows and some holy ceremony. 

    Good points Sakura, you've expressed yourself well!  Afro




    I read a book a few years back about all these nuns who'd since come out of the closet and that the biggest reason for becoming nuns was 'cause back in the day it was expected women would marry and they couldn't bring themselves to marrying a man when they were attracted to the same sex and not the male sex.

    This argument of theirs is null on this point 'cause it only applies to those who consider homosexuality as being evil. If you look at practices conducted by some nuns and priests in catholic schools where child-abuse and sexual abuse went on/still happens, all I can say is this:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-15256764

    and

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-stoke-staffordshire-12780538

    Child abuse happens, whether by those who are "celebate" or those who are married with kids.

    Exactly, why are women being compared to gems, it just shows up the whole thinking behind it that women are possesion, owned, property. It's not freedom, it's owning a woman, and even if we women were treated as precious as gems, I certainly wouldn't want to be owned, it goes with the whole argument as to why women should cover up, 'cause they are their husband's property and another man might want to steal her.

    With embarrassment, I used to quote the argument of women being like gems. Very embarrassed about it now lol. Where was my head back then?....





    Oh wow I never even thought of that with the nuns thing  Cheesy. Priests also abuse boys not women, in terms of church scandals. So this 'best men' idea comes from have a narrow-minded view that, being gay isn't a thing, pedophilia isn't  thing or that marrying will cure someone of those feelings. Which is just wrong.

    Don't be embarrassed, growing up we are taught to believe in things and not question it. We ask questions and then when our parents, or elders don't know the answers they default and say well 'God knows best' so who are we to question? It's a very very hard mindset to break out of I imagine. However, hearing your past feelings makes me wonder how many Muslim women are out fighting so hard to prove to non-Muslim women, that Islam treats women better than anything else, while still having doubts deep in their heart that something is wrong or amiss.

    As I said the good thing is to save face, Muslim women are trying to prove non-Muslims wrong. So either they'll push for reform, or they'll just quit Islam entirely like you guys did. Muhammad's 'timeless' teachings and practices are having a hard time holding up in the 21st century.

    I'm really glad you guys got out of those situations and I hope more Muslim women will, not necessary leave Islam, but just be aware of how they are treated and demand better than that.

    I know these controversial hadiths about women are floating around on these forums but I can't find them all in one place.

    Da_ Dude can you tell me what specific Al-Waqi'aah you had an issue with. maybe I might point that out to my friend who sent me the site and she'll probably will ask what I think about it.

    ***~Church is where bad people go to hide~***
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #8 - May 20, 2012, 07:08 PM

    Notice how the article is written by a male? Prof. 'Abdur Rahman I. Doi. grin12
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #9 - May 20, 2012, 09:57 PM

    That explains everything >:O

    ***~Church is where bad people go to hide~***
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #10 - May 20, 2012, 10:02 PM

    Sakura, it's surat Al-Waqi'ah in the Qu'ran, the one ayat I'm referring to in particular is 56:22 I think.


  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #11 - May 20, 2012, 10:08 PM

    Sakura, it's surat Al-Waqi'ah in the Qu'ran, the one ayat I'm referring to in particular is 56:22 I think.






    Quote
    056.022
    YUSUFALI: And (there will be) Companions with beautiful, big, and lustrous eyes,-
    PICKTHAL: And (there are) fair ones with wide, lovely eyes,
    SHAKIR: And pure, beautiful ones,


    well it only saying heaven is filled with  women beautiful,  with big, and lustrous eyes..



    Do not let silence become your legacy.. Question everything   
    I renounced my faith to become a kafir, 
    the beloved betrayed me and turned in to  a Muslim
     
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #12 - May 20, 2012, 10:36 PM


    well it only saying heaven is filled with  women beautiful,  with big, and lustrous eyes..





    The joys of the translation of the Qu'ran.  Roll Eyes

    It actually says



    And we all know what houroun (houris) are.

    Ibn Kathir said of them in his tafsir that:

    Quote
    "are delightful virgins of comparable age who never had sexual intercourse with anyone, whether from mankind or Jinns, before their husbands."


  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #13 - May 20, 2012, 10:37 PM

    But how would you know? They self-repair their hymens all the time anyway, so they could have been shagging everything in sight for millennia.

    Devious, treacherous, murderous, neanderthal, sub-human of the West. bunny
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #14 - May 20, 2012, 10:51 PM

    That website is ignorant.  Christians never argued that women didn't have souls, that's an urban myth.

    "Befriend them not, Oh murtads, and give them neither parrot nor bunny."  - happymurtad's advice on trolls.
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #15 - May 20, 2012, 10:55 PM

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synod_of_M%C3%A2con

    Quote
    Contrary to popular myth, the Synods of Macon undertook no discussion on the subject of whether or not women had souls, or whether or not women were human.[4] This myth is based on a story told in The History of the Franks by St. Gregory of Tours. Gregory was bishop of Tours in the sixth century and wrote a history of the region. At one point he tells of a council -that may, or may not, have been any of the synods at Mâcon- at which the meaning of the word "man" was discussed. Gregory writes:
    {{quotation|There came forward at this Council a certain bishop who maintained that woman could not be included under the term “man." However, he accepted the reasoning of the other bishops and did not press his case, for the holy book of the Old Testament tells us that in the beginning, when God created man, “Male and female he created them and called their name Adam,” which means earthly man; even so, he called the woman Eve, yet of both he used the word “man.”[5]


    So once again I'm left with the classic Irish man's dilemma, do I eat the potato or do I let it ferment so I can drink it later?
    My political philosophy below
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwGat4i8pJI&feature=g-vrec
    Just kidding, here are some true heros
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBTgvK6LQqA
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #16 - May 20, 2012, 11:06 PM

    One annoying thing, and this happens a lot even in academic and so called intellectual Islamic articles, is they always make side comments or comparisons to Christianity and Judaism almost habitually, ro show differences as in one was more 'advanced' than another ( Christians and Jews do the same thing). It's annoying because being the most 'enlightened' religion is like saying your the smartest kid on the short bus.   I think it shows the inherent one upsman ship and bullshit jockeying that goes on between these stupid ideas of being ' the one true religion'.  it also shows a hidden kind of cultural supremacy and imperialism as well because the comparisons are always between the religions where they conflicted like Islam vs Hinduism, or Islam vs Christianity, or Christianity vs Judiaism.  Shintoism and Native American religions never get compared.  

    So once again I'm left with the classic Irish man's dilemma, do I eat the potato or do I let it ferment so I can drink it later?
    My political philosophy below
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwGat4i8pJI&feature=g-vrec
    Just kidding, here are some true heros
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBTgvK6LQqA
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #17 - May 21, 2012, 12:10 AM

    But how would you know? They self-repair their hymens all the time anyway, so they could have been shagging everything in sight for millennia.


    True, it kind of presents an oxymoron doesn't it?

    Women who are eternal virgins, yet supposedly never touched before marrying their husbands in heaven, which begs the question of the subject of virginity in Islam being kind of confused. And considering that the majourity of people in jahannam will be women, it throws out the whole argument by appologists that the reason men will have multiple wives and houris in jannah is because Allah loves women so much that women will outnumber men in jannah and need a husband too. Just so many wholes in the arguments of daee' (dawahghandists).

    I find it interesting the whole thing about jinn, like how the fuck are jinn supposed to fuck a woman? I remember reading something about how if a husband and wife have sex without saying the man saying the dua' beforehand, than the jinn can get on the end of the man's penis and fuck the woman too.  Cheesy And that was a salafi source too based on strong hadith. But can jinn have sex with a woman in other situations than this? I don't know, can't remember hearing or reading anything to that means.

    Jinn are supposedly immaterial most of the time, so how do they do these things? Is it comparable to a ghost fucking, or getting hurt? Some crazy shit! I remember reading 'ulema saying that jinn will hurt a person or possess them if a person hurts them whether on purpose or accidently, like if a person chucks a hot pot, they could accidently hurt the jinn and then the jinn would be on a mission to make you pay.

  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #18 - May 21, 2012, 12:17 AM

    The whole jinns having sex thing could be a good wind up for an Islamic Q&A site, if anyone feels like having some fun.

    Devious, treacherous, murderous, neanderthal, sub-human of the West. bunny
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #19 - May 21, 2012, 12:23 AM

    Quote


    I find it interesting the whole thing about jinn, like how the fuck are jinn supposed to fuck a woman? I remember reading something about how if a husband and wife have sex without saying the man saying the dua' beforehand, than the jinn can get on the end of the man's penis and fuck the woman too.  Cheesy And that was a salafi source too based on strong hadith. But can jinn have sex with a woman in other situations than this? I don't know, can't remember hearing or reading anything to that means.

      

    If this is true then i need to get a mullah to tell me how to get a hot female jinn on my dick.  Cheesy  Cheesy  Cheesy

    In my opinion a life without curiosity is not a life worth living
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #20 - May 21, 2012, 12:25 AM

    The whole jinns having sex thing could be a good wind up for an Islamic Q&A site, if anyone feels like having some fun.

       

    Just put this on my things to do after exams are done list  Smiley

    In my opinion a life without curiosity is not a life worth living
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #21 - May 21, 2012, 01:17 AM

    The whole jinns having sex thing could be a good wind up for an Islamic Q&A site, if anyone feels like having some fun.

    Sounds like fun!  dance How to go about putting it to them so that they won't ignore the question as they have done before to so many of the things I've asked them.

     

    If this is true then i need to get a mullah to tell me how to get a hot female jinn on my dick.  Cheesy  Cheesy  Cheesy


     Cheesy Cheesy Cheesy
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #22 - May 21, 2012, 01:19 AM

    I'm gonna create another thread solely for the purposes of jinn.  dance
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #23 - May 21, 2012, 02:30 AM

    It's like trying to convince people that riding a car is far quicker than riding a bike therefore it's the fastest mode of transport. These logical fallacies Muslims spew in order to get new adherents reeks of desperation.
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #24 - May 21, 2012, 02:31 AM

    Interesting website and points, Sakura.

    But where is verse 4:34 in that article? That was the first thing that popped up in my head (of many other stuff - as the ones you have elaborated on). Seems like they are dodging that holy-MashaAllah-Alhamdulilah-SubhanAllah-verse. How come?  Wink

    "Beauty is truth, truth beauty," - that is all
            Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.

    - John Keats
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #25 - May 21, 2012, 03:28 AM

    ohhh what's verse 4:34?
    Yeah my Muslims friend sent that to me, to give me some insight. :3
    I'm debating whether or not I should gently give her my true feelings on the website she sent me. I rather just nod and agree to avoid any kind of conflict. Or maybe I should poke her brain. Everytime I ask her something controversial she's like. " hmmm i don't know I'll have to ask my Imam and get back to you" .. And she never does...But she's a sweetheart she calls me her sister knowing full well I'm Aethist. Very confusing.

    ***~Church is where bad people go to hide~***
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #26 - May 21, 2012, 04:03 AM

     
    Quote
       {...Wa allaatiy takhaafoona nushoozahunna fa'idhoohunna wahjuroohunna fiy al-madhaaji'i wadhriboohunna fa in ata'nakum falaa tabghoo 'alaihinna sabeelan inna Allaha kaana 'aliyyan kabeeran.}
        {...And (as for) those (women) from whom you anticipate rebellion, admonish them, avoid them in the sleeping place and hit them.  If they obey you, do not desire and further way to (harm) them.  Surely, Allah is Knowing, Great.}  An-Nisaa:34


    It's the famous verse in the Qu'ran regarding domestic violence, except most muslims wouldn't call it that, it's more along the lines of "how to keep your wife in line" and "what to do if your wife isn't making you happy enough". It's hotly debated. Islam's dirty secret that isn't so secret.

    The whole seesaw of miswaak vs punch, and tap vs beat. It all hinges on two little words, darb/idhriboo and nushooz. And the whole thing of what does nushooz mean, is it "your wife is a slut" or "your wife left islam" or "your wife is drunk" so therefore needs to be "tapped" so that she will leave her evil ways, or is it more along the lines of, "my wife is annoying so I'm gonna teach her a fucking lesson she'll never forget".

    Semantics. Semantics. Semantics.

  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #27 - May 21, 2012, 12:49 PM

    If it is true (and so far I haven't seen proof) that pre-islam used to bury their daughters, then to them it would have been somewhat normal to do it/consider it, or rail against it.


    I know eaxactly what you mean Berbs. I have had some trouble trying to find any real evidence of this. This is what I have found:

    From Ibn Ishaq (Chapter 2):

    Quote
    The fourth man, Zayd, became neither Jew nor Christian, although he renounced the religion of the Quraysh and aban­doned idols, blood, and sacrifices slain for idols, and condemned the burying alive of female infants.

     

    From various Hadith:

    Quote
    Volume 8, Book 73, Number 6:
    Narrated Al-Mughira:
    The Prophet said, "Allah has forbidden you ( 1 ) to be undutiful to your mothers (2) to withhold (what you should give) or (3) demand (what you do not deserve), and (4) to bury your daughters alive. And Allah has disliked that (A) you talk too much about others ( B), ask too many questions (in religion), or (C) waste your property."

     

    Quote
    Book 41, Number 5127:
    Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas:
    The Prophet (peace_be_upon_him) said: If anyone has a female child, and does not bury her alive, or slight her, or prefer his children (i.e. the male ones) to her, Allah will bring him into Paradise. Uthman did not mention "male children".

     

    It seems to me that it did happen. Though as to how common it was, who can say? The frequency of the practice may have been exaggerated by early Muslims to demonize their enemies.

    Greek and Roman authors wrote in abundance about how the Carthaginians would sacrifice their children to their gods. But many historians have just seen this as propoganda against a people that they were often at war with. Even though there is even some archaeological evidence at Carthage to back up child sacrifice, many scholars still won't commit to it as something that definately happened. There is a summary on wikipedia of it here:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_sacrifice#Phoenicia_and_Carthage

    The evidence for burying children alive amongst Pagan Arabs seems to be more sparse yet everyone seems to accept it as a common practice.

    Yes we know When Islam and Mo' came, thousands of years ago the treatment of women was improved. I completely agree.


    Do you really? I really want to read up on this from an objective source. Can you recommend any book that has looked at this issue objectively and presented the evidence?

    I know there are things in the Koran about how women should be entitled to half the man's inheritance, etc. But how can we know for sure that this was an improvement on the old system? Or perhaps this was already the established practice and Muhammad was just reinforcing it? Just because something is in the Koran then that does not mean that it was something that was radically new and unheard of before. If we were to follow that logic, then we would conclude from Koran 4:34 that Pre-Islamic men were not allowed to beat their wives. Which would be ridiculous.
  • Re: Another Islam treats women great site. (some thoughts)
     Reply #28 - May 21, 2012, 01:14 PM

    Quote
    BerberElla : If it is true (and so far I haven't seen proof) that pre-islam used to bury their daughters, then to them it would have been somewhat normal to do it/consider it, or rail against it.

    I know eaxactly what you mean Berbs. I have had some trouble trying to find any real evidence of this. This is what I have found:

    From Ibn Ishaq (Chapter 2):
     

    From various Hadith:
     
     

    It seems to me that it did happen. Though as to how common it was, who can say? The frequency of the practice may have been exaggerated by early Muslims to demonize their enemies.
    ......................


    Pre-Islamic Arbaia is a very very important subject that need to be explored further   Tonyt., I tried that subject in number of forums and it is hard to get proper references on that.


    The simplest fact that Prophet's first wife Khadija was 40 year old lady having business and marrying a 25 year old guy is at terrible odds with the story Islamic baboons highlight all over Islamic websites and books on women of pre-Islamic Arabia., It is possible some Idiots in the center of desert might have done/doing that, but it can not be norm of that time specially in and around alleged famous  towns of that time Mecca and Madina..

    Any way I wish someone could write  some decent book/s on that..

    Do not let silence become your legacy.. Question everything   
    I renounced my faith to become a kafir, 
    the beloved betrayed me and turned in to  a Muslim
     
  • 1« Previous thread | Next thread »