Yes it should be illegal, just like drugs, theft, murder etc etc. We can't make the legal because we fear they go underground.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/73144/73144a3018eb9ae5be6554df56efa06e94639c06" alt="Roll Eyes"
How are drugs anything like theft or murder-- the latter two involve violating the rights of another, the former is a personal choice, regardless of what social ills/externalities it may cause. And the Drug War has been a failure at everything
except for increasing violence and organized crime, increasing the incarceration rate, stripping away civil liberties, and turning Western republics into police states. Sheesh.
Those people who make these "benefits of circumcision" arguments annoy me.
Yeah, fuckin doctors.
I wonder if you'd have rescued him if someone was about to punch him in the face, or bugger him? Sure you would, but if the person doing the harm is your "beloved wife" then it's okay. Just like those mothers who turn a blind eye to the sexual abuse of their children because they love their husband/partner.
Well, you've still got the big one. You either let him go and be brainwashed or you protect him from all that bullshit and let him make up his own mind when he is a teenager. He might hate you for allowing this to happen to him, but he'll probably hate you a lot more if he gets brainwashed and later finds out your are a Kaffir.
Is she worth it? Really?
These are completely hyperbolic analogies. I am circumcised, not for religious reasons, like 90% of males my age in the US are, as it's fairly standard medical practice here. I still enjoy sex and I'm not traumatized. Most of us who are circumcised are doing just fine and don't obsess over our missing foreskin. I'd like to hear you say to someone's face who was raped as a child, that male circumcision is on the same level as their violation. When you get back from the ER, tell me how it went.