Very interesting video !
Here are some of my thoughts, obviously I didn't put down every single one of them and I obviously directed them more towards Abdullah's comments than Farhan's.
0:41:53 - 0:41: "Everlasting is not infinite. Hell is not infinite, it is finite.. but it is everlasting! Something different!"
0:44:40 "Why should he not punish those who associate partners with him forever" I say, "why should he not" *facepalm*
0:45:50 How the heck can you reject God "without end" if you only have a finite time on earth.
0:46:30- 0:46:40 Complete nonsense. Typical "Quran says so, so it is true. Nevermind if it doesn't make sense, it's in the Quran!!"
0:47:00 - 0:47:20 Kuffar want to burn in hell for millions of years, to be able to drink one glass of wine on earth, therefore eternal torture is fair? This is comical
0:47:28 "I have demonstrated rationally with the support of Islamic sources"
0:47:49 Complete copout. "Hell is just because Allah said so"
1:04:30 That's exactly the kind of advice religious people need to follow.
1:05:30 1:06:50 - Torture is digusting, unless God does it... Come on!
1:08:00 Allah is a huge baby. If you insult him he is very justified in torturing you eternally
1:08:45 "Why would burning off someone's skin and replacing it to start the process over be cruel?" *facepalm*
1:10:00 "It's bad to make your earthly experience enjoyable" but it's good to want to get to heaven for eternal enjoyment?
1:10:33 "Within the framework of Islam it isn't cruel" And that is the whole problem of religion, denial and rejection of the real world.
1:12:58 "It's worse to burn someone at the stake for murder and rape than it is for God to torture someone eternally for not believing in him"
1:41:50 "If you get punished Islamically on earth, you don't get punished in the afterlife" Is this true? I've never heard anything of the short.
1:57:50 "Being judged by intention rather than action doesn't cause any problems" Come on, Hitler only wanted what was good for his German people, his intentions were good, but horribly misguided and deluded.
1:49:20 "You only think hell is bad because of your caring for human beings" I like how he presents that as something bad!
Near the end, was it uncomfortable for you to publicly clearly declare yourself an apostate in a room full of Muslims?
Overall I must say good job. Having never been religious I always fail to understand how a good person who is fully against suffering and torture rationalizes and approves God doing the WORST torture, I just don't get the mental and emotional gymnastics people intentionally put themselves through.
Topic: Is Hell Just Debate. Farhan Qureshi vs. Abdullah al-Andalusi