I found it kind of appealing too when I first felt that I had left Islam. Probably because to me, it seemed like a religion without any religion, if that makes any sense. It seemed like I get all the good bits of religion but without any of the dogma.
When I was young and still thought I was Muslim, I was shocked to learn about the Pagans and Wiccans. I had thought the only religions in the world were (in order of importance and with all the incorrect statements attached to them):
Islam (the right religion, if only people understood the "real" Islam)
Christianity (the incomplete religion)
Hinduism (the crazy monkeys and snakes worshipping religion)
Judaism (the old, outdated desert roamers)
Buddhism (worship of Buddha)
This is the bias most Muslims, especially the majority from South Asia are raised with.
Paganism, Wicca, Native American Shamanisms, Zoroastrianism, Taoism, and others were all different philosophies I learned about when I actively began to try to understand how other people in the world live and think. It was a shock to me to know that most regions of the world were matriarchal for most of human history. The "earth-based" paths attracted the part of me that was sick of religion and philosophy being so rooted only in the mind and the sexual repression of the major religions.
I still respect earth based religions a lot more than the Abrahamic (god loves you and makes you suffer and you can go ahead and rape the planet because you are the shit but do hate the world as you rape it and you'll star in god's eternal porn) religions.
I don't follow any religion but I think there's a lot of wisdom in all those non-Abrahamic religions that can be incorporated and utilized in a secular, naturalistic, philosophy. Like respect for other sentient beings, respect for nature, celebration of sexuality and the body, egalitarianism in gender, acceptance of sexual diversity, etc. Not every non-Abrahamic religion is equal in all these aspects, but at least they're not as cancerous as the Abrahamic 3.