Re: Losing my Religion
Reply #40 - September 05, 2011, 04:27 AM
To believe in some parts of a religion (islam) does not make you a muslim, and doesn't exempt you from being an atheist either. To be a muslim you have to believe in the entirity- all the message(s), all the quran. This is done easily by many who mould islam to suit their own ideas of morality etc. However, realistically, there is a general norm that you should adhere to re quran. One can't say the whole thing is false, as some parts are plain observations. For example, saying men, mostly, are stronger than women is not a lie, it's an observable fact. However, saying things like women are naturally inferior, making false science claims, etc are obviously incorrect
Regarding the supernatural *meh* you can believe in stuff and be atheist. There are many atheists who believe in magic, aliens, ghosts, etc. In fact, you can also believe in god (be a theist) and not be muslim.
If the message is divine then no parts would be wrong. If even one part is wrong then the whole thing is proven as written by man, not divinity.