Thanks for your post.
Good to hear you will visit us periodically, I'd be interested to hear more about your angle on a range of topical issues as a practicising theist with a background in science.
Questions are always welcome.
All answers are my own and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, and understandings of allother Jews.
I won't bore you with the details, but I'm curious - no doubt you have heard them countless times before, but what is your interpratation of Islam's attitudes towards Jews in the Quran and particularly the Hadith?
To be fair, I cannot say I have read or seen all comments regarding Jews and Judaism in the Hadiths.
Those I have read and been shown from the Quran and Hadiths have mostly been concerning--in their generalizations, negativity, and lack of Muslim self-assessment (what is claimed as failings of "Jews" is unrecognized as equally true of Muslims, and all hman beings).
Do you believe religion should be interpreted as it was intended, or adapted to suit the current landscape?
I do not see a difference. The essence of G-d's Teachings is for ethical and righteous human behavior. This is what makes these Teachings eternal. Additionally, if one understands the only way to correctly interpret His Word is as per Mishlei (Proverbs) 3:17, "
Her ways are ways of pleasantness, and all her paths are peace," then any interpretation that appears contrary to this need be accepted as misinterpreted. Jews, generally speaking, are not Biblical literalists, and we are taught the Spirit of the Law trumps the letter of the law. We also believe that G-d's Word is not also Eternal, but it is a Living Word. Thus it contains the answers to all questions (in regard to appropriate human behavior) for every circumstance that confronts each successive generation. As we mature (individually and a species) intellectually and, we hope, spiritually and ethically, as we gain greater knowledge of His universe, we appreciate fuller and deeper meanings in His Word.
Who was Mohammed?
a) prophet
b) saint
c) ordinary man
d) deluded
e) conman
f) other, please specify
All of the above--depending on who you ask, and depending on what circumstances.
I would answer the same for any human being.
But I am sure you do not what such a glib answer.
However true.
Personally, I believe Mohammed was a charismatic man and a brilliant military strategist. He found inspiration from the monotheism of Jews and Christians. He was not a "Prophet" per Jewish definition of the term, nor a "saint" per the Christian one. He had visions, we are told, and (speaking as a physician) I wonder if he suffered from epilepsy. He was a fellow man. And, thus shared our failings. He gained power over others and, at times, this inspired him to do good and, at times, to do evil--at least from my perspective.
Also are you sure there is a God, or do you accept it could all be hogwash?
I've decided, for me, I believe G-d exists.
And whenever I have had doubts in my life, I find in assuming He exists, my Life has greater meaning, purpose, and understanding.
I respect those who may hold differing opinions--particularly if it similar provides them the same inspiration to live a life that is kind, compassionate, and caring toward others.
Interestingly, the older I get, the stronger my belief in G-d, Blessed be His Name.
Respectfully,
History
Topic: History