osmanthus
Yes but how is praying for them supposed to help? You seem to be glossing over the basic problem
Because they believe the Saints will be there advocate.
It goes like this:
In short, you claim to believe in a god that can always be trusted to do the right thing at the right time for the right reasons. All other beings (saints included) are less perfect and less knowledgeable, and therefore haven't got the same grasp of the situation that your god has. So, why would you ask one of them to interfere? It doesn't make any sense.
Because for some reason Catholics believe the Saints have special privaleges in Heaven.
Why would you even make any request to God yourself? If he wants your friends to live, they'll live. If he wants them to die, they'll die. If you ask him to do something that you would like him to do, you are effectively telling him how to run the universe (or at least the bits of it that interest you).
We do this to show love for others.
Now you'll probably claim that you aren't doing that at all, but there's no way you'll be able to support that claim. If you make a request of your infallible god, you are implying that he is fallible. If he was not fallible, there would be no reason to ever make a request. The only conclusions that can be drawn are that people who pray for things, anything at all, don't really believe in the sort of deity they claim to believe in, or alternatively they have never really considered what their belief actually means.
I'm sorry I disagree with you. God is not fallible.
I see Quod has already given you a nudge about this. So, question stll remains: why is it idolatry when non-Christians do it, but not idolatry when Christians do it?
I already responded to QSE's inquiry. Please read my previous posts as I don't like to repeat myself.